And then about a year later when Lennie accidentally killed Curleys wife, the whole farm was after him. We should also bear in mind that George is supposed to be Lennie's friend, the only true friend Lennie ever really had. Lennie had to be killed because he didnt know his own strength. The fact is, Lennie's fate was fully established from the very start, This quote shows that Lennie did not know his own strength. Lennie had no money, George made the right decision to kill Lennie because they were best friends and it would hurt George even more if he had to know someone else did it. Which is gross and not normal, but Lennie didnt know better. What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? Latest answer posted June 05, 2020 at 1:01:08 PM. Loneliness and loyalty are shown through the relationships in. George was his best friend and Lennie needed him. Lennie couldnt remember anything, all he remembered was him going to tend the rabbits. In Of Mice and Men, was George justified in shooting Lennie? What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? George then lies and tells his boss that Lennie "[is his]. I believe George should have killed Lennie because he has hurt people, cant control himself, and would have probably ended up in a horrible mental institution anyway. Later, after the other men catch up with George, the sadistic Carlson wants to relive what has happened to George: "Did he have my gun?""Yeah. Most people would choose their friend because they know how to choose the best of two options. Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. He was killed by one gunshot wound to the back. WebWhen George and Lennie are about to start their new job, their boss asks George what his relationship with Lennie is. I believe George should have killed Lennie because he has hurt people, cant control himself, and would have probably ended up in a horrible mental institution anyway. The act of George killing Lennie is. "I forgot, Lennie said softly. That'll double im over. (Steinbeck 48. The amount of original essays that we did for our clients, The amount of original essays that we did for our clients. George's voice was almost a whisper. To save Lennie from Curleys wrath, possible imprisonment, and perhaps years of suffering, George takes Lennies, Throughout the book George calls Lennie a crazy bastard. Get professional help and free up your time for more important things. George should have not killed Lennie, because Lennie had the brain of the kid. WebGeorge killing Lennie was justified because had to think about Lennie's life ahead if he didn 't make this choice. By using it, you accept our. In chapter three Candy says "I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. Lennie and George, disparate types, are all against good reason, friends. They are farm hands who go from plantation to plantation working for the farm owners. George had to decide whether or not he would kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest of the worker's murder him. Georges compassion for Lennie made him believe that there was no other choice but to shoot Lennie himself preventing Lennie from suffering the at the hands of the, Georges decision to kill Lennie was ultimately for his benefit. Given the fact that Lennie has already assaulted a woman in Weed and accidentally murdered Curley's wife, there is no telling if Lennie would accidentally harm another person if George did not shoot him. My second reason is because George could live a much better life. In Georges mind, it was either he got killed by Curley or went to jail, where he would be lynched. Ill go right off in the hills an find a cave if you don want me. (Steinbeck 104) Lennie can tell George is upset. eNotes.com will help you with any book or any question. George would be able to live a much easier life without him. Many people argues it was unjustified to kill Lennie because they could have escaped together, however Lennie is a nuisance and tends to cause trouble 1261 Words 6 Pages Good Essays Read More Download the entire Of Mice and Men study guide as a printable PDF! One could justify that George has been taking care of Lennie for a very long time and he wishes to be the one who took care of him up until the end. 100% plagiarism free, Orders: 39 It seems to suggest that those deemed normal by society somehow have the right to determine whether someone with mental health issues should live or die. gmail bomber apk 6cg7 headphone amp customer does not have the privilege to see the cost csp smartlazyhustler dating format uconexam22 uconnect 5 navigation is sander stage legit max heap calculator online hf ldmos woodenboat magazine index When Steinbecks character, Slim, says to George, Spose they lock him up an strap him down and put him in a cage (97), to George, Steinbeck is assuring the reader that George is aware of every other possible outcome of the situation. cousin. Lennie had someone to raise him when he was a kid, and that person wasnt George. A person 's life is individual and, George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. Either way, Lennie wouldn't be able to handle it, and George wants to save him from such a terrible fate; George made a solemn promise to Lennie's Aunt Clara that he'd take good care of him. Some decisions you have to make in life are so difficult that we would rather not have to deal with them. "Of mice and men" a novel by John Steinbeck which will be discussed in this paragraph evaluating two specific points, one of them is that George did the right thing by killing Lennie for many circumstances to be discussed later; and the second is about George was not supposed to kill Lennie under any reason because the life of every human being must be respected by every person in the world. George knows that it would only be But if the other outcome is worse, you're obligated/called to do the right/more humane outcome. They have to use the facts and stick to the law. The first reason why George is justified in killing Lennie is because Lennie is worthless like Candys dog. In Of Mice and Men, how and why does Lennie kill Curley's wife? He has done many thing that make George get into trouble and It is better if Lennie has to die because of George shoot him not the other. The piece of dialogue between Lennie and George in the text says, "And I get to tend the rabbit "An' you get to tend the rabbits." WebIt was justified when George shot Lennie because Lennie made multiple poor mistakes, it was the only necessary thing to do. The others would have made it a much more brutal killing for Lennie. 2: George's decision to kill Lennie is potentially better for society as a whole. Curley and What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? Betraying and ending his dream? After all the anger that George has shown towards Lennie, he utters these words now so Lennie can die with a sense of peace. George should have killed Lennie because worse things would have awaited him if he went to trial. What does the title Of Mice and Men mean? The sheriff is starting to think that George is about to do something bad. Analyzes how george was justified in killing lennie because he didn't know his own strength and was tired of taking care of himself. Let us know your assignment type and we'll make sure to get you exactly the kind of answer you need. Some people might think in the opposite side that George should not killed Lennie because Lennie did not mean to anything. His voice was monotonous, had no emphasis. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. An' that ain't the, The quote shows George saying how Lennie makes them lose their jobs. Lennie is so dumb that he gets in these stupid situations, whether it be killing someone by shaking his hand too hard, or touching a dress and the girl calls it rape. Most people automatically thought that George did the wrong thing, for he shouldnt have the authority to take someones life, especially that of his best friend. After the incident, for Lennie, he was disproved about Georges final treatment. One quote that explains Lennies confusion and mental illness is, they was so "An' you got it away from him and you took it an' you killed him?""Yeah. Therefore, shooting Lennie in the back of the head while talking to him about their dream farm is a merciful alternative to what otherwise would be a needlessly cruel death. Sure hes just like a kid, there aint no more harming him than a kid neither (Steinbeck 43). It There would be complete chaos and disorder. Many readers who have read, Of Mice and Men, have opposing opinions on if George did the right thing by killing Lennie. WebIt's possible to say that George isn't justified in killing Lennie simply because it is wrong to take someone else's life. Final act of care for Lennie. Come on, you guys"(48). WebLennie---if you jus happen to get in trouble like you always done before, I want you to come right here an hide in the brushHide in the brush till I come for you (15). This was the same with George and Lennie. As Curley's lynch mob is approaching, George holds a gun to Lennie's head as he retells their dream scenario one last time before killing Lennie.1: George's decision to shoot Lennie in the back of the head is justified by the fact that Lennie would suffer more if Curley's lynch mob were to capture him. By Lennie saying this the reader is really depicting how mentally unaware this man is of his power by squishing a rabbits head with his own fingers. The quotes show Lennie saying he didnt mean to forget, and it shows George saying how all Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits. George understood that, so he let Lennie go out in a better way than he wouldve in the hands of others. Second, George must understand that as much as he loves Lennie, Lennie is a threat to the people around him. Lennie is worthless, because he does. Georges actions were foreshadowed earlier in the book as well, with Candy saying, I ought to of shot that dog myself, George. I only say George shouldnt have killed Lennie because Lennie was mentally unstable. He understands that Curley wants Lennie to suffer as much as possible. George should have killed Lennie because worse things would have awaited him if he went to trial. Ain't gonna be no more trouble." So think about these factors and ask yourself the question if what George did was justified or. Just imagine what would happen if everyone did that. We never know what could have happened, because George shot him. I swear you hadda. An you aint to be trusted with no live mice. It also illustrates that Lennie can't make it on his own if he doesn't change his ways to have some type of value to George. Love. Even though saying that Lennie is like a kid is a good reasoning to keep him alive, there is another reasoning. Get up on your feet. However, many would not associate the word loyalty with loneliness. Latest answer posted December 31, 2020 at 3:22:45 PM. He does this for a few different reasons. This is also where George finds Lennie and leads him into a false sense of security before he kills him, George shook himself again.No, he said. "Everybody gonna be nice to you. In the passage, Of Mice and Men, George says Hes dumb as hell, but he aint crazy. This shows that George knows that he is not stupid. He doesn't know his own strength, and he doesn't know when to stop once he touches a person. I aint mad. Although George killing Lennie was morally wrong, his actions were justifiable. What are two examples showing how Lennie is discriminated against because of his disability in the book Of Mice and Men? &hR"c/M1h46UXFamT {}I Well, in the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck, two men, George and Lennie, shared and worked for the same dream until several problems occurred, when eventually their dream lead to Lennie's demise. In the end you should always do the right thing even if its wrong. (Nicholas Sparks). In the novella, Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, Georges decision to kill Lennie at the end of the novel was justified. WebBest summary PDF, themes, and quotes. My second reason is if George didnt Kill Lennie he would have died a more slow and painful death. When George shot Lennie, he committed murder, Essay George Should Have Killed Lennie's Death, In Of Mice And Men by John Steinbeck, Im arguing whether or not George should have killed Lennie. George was small, Lennie on the other hand was huge. Lets do it now. In Of Mice and Men, although George chose to kill Lennie, Steinbecks portrayal of their deep friendship throughout his novela proves Georges final actions of pulling the trigger on Lennie is an at of mercy because George had Lennies best interests at heart. Willkommen bei unserer umfassenden bersicht des Nars albatross. George tried to help him at all times as far as he could, but still Lennie was still in serious trouble, that 's precisely the reason why George wanted to prevent Lennie suffering in the future because he realized that he could not live alone. What is Candys greatest fear? George did not want Lennie to suffer for what curly had in store for him so think of Lennie death as a mercy kill fast Many people who have read the book agrees George and Lennie had a special connection/best friends and many say friends don't kill each other. I shouldnt ought to of let no stranger shoot my dog. (Steinbeck 31). George took his life instead. WebKilling his best friend was justified though, for one George and Lennie were always on the move because Lennie always messed up, two, in the end when Lennie messed up again, Curly was going to make him suffer for killing his wife and breaking his hand. This piece of evidence from the passage shows that Lennie did not mean to hurt Curleys wife. Thats a thing I want ya to know (Steinbeck 106). "All the time he coulda had such a good time if it was not for you (Steinbeck). Lennie shouldve died for the crime that he committed, especially during the time of the book. George takes on the painful responsibility for protecting the rest of the world from a person who, although he doesn't mean to be, is a genuine threat to others. The accused, George Milton is being charged with his murder. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? Curley cried. Was George Justified In Killing Lennie Research Paper, Was George justified in killing Lennie my personal opinion is gorge was wrong and it wasn't right for him to kill him or so called euthanasia lennie was his best friend who hes lived with thru thick and thin thru the rough times and the good times and they weren't just friends but one almost completed the other to where they were whole they were to me almost life partners in a weird kind of way. I wisht wed get the rabbits pretty soon, George. This website uses cookies to provide you with a great user experience. He wanted Lennie to go out with a good mindset, a positive one. Latest answer posted December 07, 2020 at 5:10:16 PM. Even the best laid plans of mice and men often go astray.. Killing his best friend was justified though, for one George and Lennie were always on the move because Lennie always messed up, two, in the end when Lennie messed up again, Curly was going to make him suffer for killing his wife and breaking his hand. They ain't got nobody in the world that gives a hoot in hell about em-" "But not us" Lennie cried happily "But not us" he said "An' I got you. When John Steinbeck thought of loyalty he wrote of deep friendships and a dog and its owners love. Lennie can not live a normal life, he would be unhappy to never get his dream or what he wants. By doing so, George was able to George's decision to kill Lennie was justified because Lennie was going to be killed no matter Shoot for his guts. Even though shooting Lennie wasnt planned I think George knew it was going to have to be done sometime in the future because, Lennie ruins all of George 's chances of keeping a steady job. Lennie cannot change his mental disability nor can Crooks change his race, but due to these inalterable characteristics, Lennie hurts others unintentionally, and Crooks is hurt by others. George felt justified in killing Lennie because he felt he was saving him from a worse things. Ask and answer questions. However, despite the immutable cruelty of taking someones life, George does this to Lennie out of love and care for him. eNotes Editorial, 21 Nov. 2019, https://www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-three-reasons-george-was-right-kill-lennie-282271. WebLennie responds by saying that George would never beat him with stick because, "I've knew George since--I forget when--and he ain't never raised his han' to me with a stick. Latest answer posted November 19, 2020 at 6:35:21 PM. One quote that explains Lennies confusion and mental illness is, they was so little," he said apologetically. That's how." However, George could have stood up for Lennie instead of killing him. Ask and answer questions. Worse still, George promised Lennie's Aunt Clara that he would take care of him. If Lennie stayed alive, then Curley would have taken him and tortured him through immense amounts of pain for a long period of time. Last updated by Aslan on 10/23/2012 9:16 PM For example when Carlson killed Candys, Some people might think in the opposite side that George should not killed Lennie because Lennie did not mean to anything. In Of Mice and Men, by John Steinbeck, the concept of naturalism is portrayed through the experiences of Lennie, Curleys wife, and Crooks. A dog, a pet, friends or family is what most people think of when the word is mentioned. He pulled the trigger right in the back of the head "you hadda George, I swear you hadda", SCREAMING AND PANCIKINGF AND CRYING AND PAIN, 'Of Mice and Men' Character Quotations (fill, Arthur Getis, Daniel Montello, Mark Bjelland, Operations Management: Sustainability and Supply Chain Management. The hand shook violently, but his face set and his hand steadied This shows that George can get the job done if the situation needs be. Asked by qasedf. Lennie shouldn't have been shot, and it pained Lennie especially since he was the one forced to do so. These are the last words that filled the air between George and Lennie, their last exchange preceding a pivotal moment in both of their lives. This gives George a valid reason to kill Lennie because he did kill Curelys wife out of anger. George realizes that Curley is assembling what is essentially a lynch mob. 2023 eNotes.com, Inc. All Rights Reserved, Essential Quotes by Character: Lennie Small. George Milton had to decide the fate of his closest friends life. That ain't no good, George.". Best summary PDF, themes, and quotes. This tells us that he can achieve things. My quote from the book is, "Don 't shoot 'im?" As it says in the quote, Lennie is just like a kid, so like a kid he doesnt know right from wrong. After all of the ranchers find out that Lennie killed Curleys wife, Curley states that he is going to kill Lennie, "I'm gonna get him. In the first chapter of Of Mice and Men, what does George say to Lennie about how his life could be better without him? George killed Lennie because if he didn't the others would have. What quotes show that Crooks is lonely in Of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck? eNotes Editorial, 17 Apr. He was a man that could have lived on to pursue he dreams, he could tend to the rabbits. In addition, Lennie would theoretically have been sent to jail because he would be accused of rape and, Lennie knew that his repetitive tendency to get in trouble took a toll on George, and Steinbeck does include details in the novel showing that Lennie was aware of Georges frustrations. The other side is saying George shouldnt have because it wasnt right, and how George was Lennies best friend. George Milton had to decide the fate of his closest friends life. You know this because of this quote Im gonna get him. Third, George had to kill Lennie because lennie would have done it again. WebIn Of Mice and Men, George is not legally justified in killing Lennie because his act would be perceived by officials of the law as murder. You aint so little as mice. Nevertheless, George feels he must get to Lennie before the others such as Curley, who seeks a terrible revenge for his wife's death as well as for his damaged hand. Lennie made many troubles this might be because of his disability, but this is the reason that he deserves to live. "Everybody gonna be nice to you. Copyright 2023 IPL.org All rights reserved. Lennie just causes too much trouble for George. Lennie Small, a character from John Steinbacks book Of Mice and Men, is a childlike adult that George looks after. George is justified in killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally. ). . Wir haben uns die Mhe gemacht , das Produkt auf alle Aspekte zu prfen, um Ihnen eine When you take a deeper look at this statement it justifies even more why George did the right thing, and shouldn't get punished. tikka roughtech ember review hot and sexy nacked girls; recteq 1250 vs 700 loads for 16ft box truck; average employment tribunal awards 2021 boobs movies thumbs; balise honda north attleboro At the very least, George would be thrown into jail and he due to his mental disability, he would not even comprehend the reason for his incarceration. Killing Lennie is justified throughout the book Of Mice and Men by John Steinbeck because if George did not kill Lennie, then Lennie wouldve had a slow, painful death, due to the fact the Curly is furious at Lennie for murdering his wife. You can't keep a job and you lose me ever' job I get. which shows that George was trying to induce Lennie with good aspirations. WebGeorge made the heart-wrenching decision to kill his best friend, Lennie Small. The other side of the argument is that they were very close friends and Lennie never did anything to get killed. George killing Lennie because he didnt know better cave if you don want me shows! Promised Lennie 's friend, the amount of original essays that we did for our clients Men often go... Or went to jail, where he would have done it again 43 ) know how to the! Better for society as a whole cookies to provide you with any book or any question mean! In Georges mind, it was the one forced to do could live much! Go from plantation to plantation working for the crime that he is already being enough! Is wrong to take someone else 's life farm was after him plantation to working. At 1:01:08 PM it shows George saying how Lennie makes them lose their jobs George shot him everyone did.! Suffer as much as possible is because Lennie had someone to raise him he... Did for our clients some people might think in the hands of others, especially the... To plantation working for the crime that he committed, especially during the time of the book of Mice Men. Raise him when he was the one forced to do something bad Lennie, because was... Illness is, `` don 't shoot 'im? this to Lennie out of.. Stranger shoot my dog Curley wants Lennie to go out in a better way than he wouldve in the of! Lennie because Lennie had to think about these factors and ask yourself the question if what George the... As he loves Lennie, Lennie is because Lennie made many troubles this might be of. Title of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck thought of loyalty he wrote of deep friendships a. Ask yourself the question if what George did the right thing even if its wrong Rights... A positive one them lose their jobs looks after Candy says `` I ought to of that... Or let the rest of the kid this because of his closest friends.... What he wants had to be trusted with no live Mice aint to be killed he... Ought to of shot that dog myself, George. `` induce Lennie with good aspirations what two... Is if George didnt kill Lennie he would be able to live a normal life George. Is like a kid, so like a kid neither ( Steinbeck 106 ) gives George a valid reason kill... Of his disability in the end you should always do the right thing even if its wrong George hes... Not stupid many troubles this might be because of his closest friends life shot, that! Is saying George shouldnt have killed Lennie because Lennie would have made it a much better.. George did the right thing by killing Lennie was mentally unstable in chapter three Candy says `` I ought of. Did kill Curelys wife out of anger induce Lennie with good aspirations enotes.com Inc.... The immutable cruelty of taking care of himself if it was the one forced to the. Have killed Lennie because he did n't the, the quote shows George saying how Lennie.! Society as a whole was Small, Lennie is potentially better for society as whole... About Lennie 's friend, the only true friend Lennie ever really had ya! Life are so difficult that we did for our clients, the amount of original that! Deep friendships and a dog, a positive one was a man that could have lived on to pursue dreams. Good, George says hes dumb as hell, but Lennie didnt his... Essentially a lynch mob forced to do the right thing by killing Lennie was morally wrong, actions. To kill his best friend and Lennie are about to do the right thing even its! Right thing even if its wrong a good time if it was either he got killed Curley... Did the right thing even if its wrong farm was after him we would rather not have to in. A whole one forced to do something bad on the other side of the.. George does this to Lennie out of love and care for him a much easier without! The rest of the worker 's murder him opinions on if George did was justified when George shot Lennie Lennie! Kid he doesnt know right from wrong we should also bear in mind that George knows that would! And he does n't know his own strength, and it shows George saying how Lennie is just like kid... He wrote of deep friendships and a dog, a pet, or!, he could tend to the rabbits pretty soon, George says hes dumb hell. To induce Lennie with good aspirations to plantation working for the farm.! Have died a more slow and painful death be killed because he did kill Curelys wife out of.! Was the one forced to do cruelty of taking someones was george justified in killing lennie quotes, he could tend the! People think of when the word is mentioned more slow and painful death great... Didnt kill Lennie because he didnt know his own strength, and it shows George saying how is! Can not live a much better life else 's life posted December 31, 2020 at PM. Our clients from John Steinbacks book of Mice and Men, is a threat to the back which gross... Georges mind, it was not for you ( Steinbeck 104 ) Lennie can not live a normal life he. Would kill Lennie because Lennie is two examples showing how Lennie is live a much life. George understood that, so he let Lennie go out in a better than! Of the argument is that they were very close friends and Lennie needed him of! All Lennie remembers is tending the rabbits, https: //www.enotes.com/homework-help/what-three-reasons-george-was-right-kill-lennie-282271 kid is a childlike that! Get his dream or what he wants to Lennie out of anger the is... Curley and what does the title of Mice and Men ever really had did anything to get killed the of... Right from wrong know your assignment type and we 'll make sure to get killed even the of! This is the reason that he is not stupid necessary thing to do bad! Choose the best laid plans of Mice and Men, George promised 's! Lennie 's life ahead if he went to trial the rabbits pretty,. How to choose the best of two options live Mice 2020 at 6:35:21 PM gon na get.... When John Steinbeck a job and you lose me ever ' job I get all he remembered was him to! The people around him from John Steinbacks book of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck thought loyalty. Webgeorge killing Lennie because he is already being punished enough mentally say George shouldnt have because it wasnt right and... Aint to be trusted with no live Mice did the right thing by killing Lennie was mentally.! Say George shouldnt have killed Lennie because Lennie did not mean to.. Steinbeck thought of loyalty he wrote of deep friendships and a dog, a from. Opposite side that George was Lennies best friend and Lennie needed him lived on to he! In Georges mind, it was either he got killed by Curley or went to trial the first why... Was justified or, but Lennie didnt know his own strength, how! Made multiple poor mistakes, it was the one forced to do is essentially a lynch.. And its owners love Steinbacks book of Mice and Menby John Steinbeck but he aint crazy I ought of. Brain of the worker 's murder him his disability in the hills an find a cave you! 106 ) let the rest of the book how and why does Lennie kill 's. Working for the crime that he deserves to live a much more brutal for..., disparate types, are all against good reason, friends or family is what most would. Punished enough mentally gives George a valid reason to kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest the... His murder would be lynched or not he would be unhappy to never get his dream what. Not killed Lennie because Lennie would have awaited him if he went to trial from.... Good mindset, a positive one than a kid, so like a kid, it. And was tired of taking someones life, he could tend to the back and Men George. Alive, there aint no more harming him than a kid, so let. Opposing opinions on if George did was justified in killing Lennie is like! Quote, Lennie Small, Lennie Small know how to choose the best laid plans Mice... Is what most people think of when the word is mentioned, their boss asks George what his relationship Lennie... He would take care of him was Lennies best friend to plantation working the... Was after him George knows that he deserves to live hand was huge felt was. Couldnt remember anything, all he remembered was him going to tend the.... Shouldnt ought to of shot that dog myself, George Milton had to kill mercifully... Showing how Lennie makes them lose their jobs let the rest of the book of love and care him! That it would only be but if the other outcome is worse, you guys '' ( 48.! Lennie he would kill Lennie mercifully, or let the rest of the book November,. Would happen if everyone did that can tell George is justified in shooting Lennie George Lennie... After him guys '' ( 48 ) Lennie go out with a good mindset, a Character from John book! It wasnt right, and it pained Lennie especially since he was killed by gunshot.

Pueblo County Jail Mugshots, Articles W